“Email is dead!” Don’t quite agree, myself!

Link: The death of e-mail?

Once again, a really, really good article from the Chicago Tribune.  This one points to the fact that according to comScore Media Matrix, USA teenage email use is dropping and is being replaced by more instant alternatives.

"It’s too complicated to send e-mail," 14-year-old Jennica Paho, of San Jose, Calif., told the San Jose Mercury News last month. "I have to go in and type it, and send it, then wait for a reply."

It takes, like, you know, minutes and everything.

Seriously, though, just a little more than a decade after it hit the mainstream, e-mail already is on the way out.

I get this.

I rarely check my hotmail account.  It’s just takes too long.  I don’t like faffing around logging in and waiting for it to screw around logging me into passport servers, blah blah … and THEn it doesn’t even take me to my inbox.  It makes me CLICK again to get into my email.  As if I’ve any interest in reading the welcome page.

Yes I have an interest… but NOT when my mind is set on sending an email, or checking an email.

So the author of this article, Dave Wischnowsky, certainly has a point. 

Indeed, I really identify with this perspective:

Well, e-mailing is just too slow. And too uncertain.

"E-mail is more like snail mail. You don’t know when they’re going to get it," Alex Stikeleather, 17, of Palo Alto, Calif, explained.

This is the single reason why I use SMS.  I generally need the message to get to the person immediately.  Otherwise I’ll email it and they can pick it up whenever.

However, there is one point that makes this whole discussion null and void: Blackberry.  (Or similar – e.g. Sidekick or any near real time mobile email device).  I love it when I meet a new person who is Blackberrified.  I know that I can email them and they’ll get it as quickly as they’ll get a text.  I love the ability to be able to email them a long comment or a short quick quip…  and get a response just as soon as they’re able to.

I keep seeing photos of celebrities clutching the latest Blackberry or Sidekick.  That makes sense to me.  They can email and call as they wish.  However, it’s interesting that Paris Hilton’s sidekick or blackberry usage has done nothing whatsoever for the device.

You’d think that celebrities showing off Blackberries would really boost sales.  Not here, anyway.  I have never, ever seen a teenager or young person (e.g. under 21) using a Blackberry.   Never. 

Anyway I’ll post more on that later.  I think it’s an interesting issue.

Meanwhile, I can well believe teen email usage is dropping.  So actually, … forget the title of this post.  ;-)   I wish someone, somewhere, would start up a mobile operator that actually puts instant email and messaging into the hands of the youth, instead of limiting them to 160 characters….

About Ewan

Ewan is Founder and Editor of Mobile Industry Review. He writes about a wide variety of industry issues and is usually active on Twitter most days. You can read more about him or reach him with these details.

  • http://www.davidmccuskey.com/ david

    “I wish someone, somewhere, would start up a mobile operator that actually puts instant email and messaging into the hands of the youth, instead of limiting them to 160 characters.”

    You CAN get email access will ALL mobile providers if you have a mobile phone which has an email client, though you might need to subscribe to a data plan.
    I’ve had email on my Nokia 6600 for two years with t-mobile’s (old) $5/month data plan; I can get ‘real’ web, too using mobile Opera.
    I use it every day to keep track of multiple email accounts. This setup was also very convenient when I visited Europe and didn’t want to hunt down cybercafes.

    As for text messages, every Nokia I’ve had will allow you to write messages over the 160 character limit of SMS. When you send the message the phone does the work of splitting up the message into chunks of 160 characters.
    The Nokia message editor is top notch, too: it has a great text-entry system, allows random editing and will even do copy/paste!

    Lastly, you can set up a MyTmobile account to notify you via SMS when a new email message arrives. That way you know when you have a new email and don’t have to check every 5 minutes on your phone. I’m sure other operators have this, too.

    In short, you can have your cake and eat it, too! But you might need to change phones. :)

    david

  • http://martyndavies.livejournal.com Martyn Davies

    Certainly you can see the immediacy argument for SMS vs. email. However, a lot of the comment ignores the success of Myspace. Young people love to communicate via Myspace, yet it is just an email portal by another name. The messaging is all done on line via the browser, but it still is basically email, and you can even get spam.

Switch to our mobile site