Is it time to subscribe to a printer service from HP?

Ever since my dad brought home an...

What’s the best way of buying a phone today?

How did you buy your latest phone?...

MWC: What device highlights did you miss?

So, early last week I predicted that...

Mobile Data: Genius strategy and why you’re screwing up the mobile industry

If you really want unlimited mobile data on Vodafone, you can have it for £45 a month.

Likewise, Orange will sell you unlimited off-peak data if you buy one of their £75 a month price plans.

Of course, you can get 1gb of data for £7.50 a month from T-Mobile.

However, most people don’t want to swap. That’s where the genius operator strategy lies. I am routinely surprised by how many people I meet or talk with — this means YOU, probably — who count themselves as mobile data experts, geeks or know-alls. Invariably they have top of the range devices… and mobile data is extremely important to them….

… but they still pay £3 a meg. Or worse, £7 a meg on some o2 plans, someone was telling me the other day.

They complain. They think it’s unreasonable. They get wound up. Some begin foaming at the mouth. Within seconds, they’re listing the exact amount of money they spent on data over the last five consecutive months. It’s lots of money they’re spending.

There’s a solution, but it involves changing to T-Mobile.

Instead the Vodafone, Orange & o2 genius strategy — the gamble — is that the overwhelming majority can’t be arsed to do anything about it. They’ll experience data-creep. Before they know it, they’ll be adding an extra £15 – £20 a month in data revenues. It’ll become the norm. Yes there will be a bit of shouting, but you know, you’ve perhaps boosted APRU of this set of users by 25% and their demand is more or less inelastic. You can spin out the APRU increase for at least another year or so charging £3 a meg.

In fact, I wonder how long you all will put up with it.

How long until you say ‘£3 a meg is just stupid?’

Do you wait another year?

Do you sit and hope that the market will move?

Well. It’s already moved and it’s £3 a meg until the operators reckon enough of you are *actually* in danger of migrating to T-Mobile.

You owe it to the mobile industry to do something about this. If you own a handset purchased in the last 6 months and you catch yourself NOT using mobile data because of the cost, you have absolutely no excuse. No excuse at all. You shouldn’t have to think. You should be able to just use the data without regard for cost.

While the majority of mobile geeks around me continue to ARSE about restricting their data use to 1-2 meg a month ‘to keep the costs down,’ the industry isn’t going to move forward. Mobile podcasting will get nowhere. Mobile data services will continue to limp along. Mobile operators have little incentive to innovate much because the status quo is actually reasonably acceptable to them. There’s no need to introduce reasonably priced ‘unlimited data’ plans when no one — not even the mobile geeks — is bothering to use data more than a few meg each.

So how long will you let it go? I’ve started being direct with people now. Bring out a modern handset and proceed to send a sodding text message instead of emailing a photo up to Moblog or a viedo to Nakama, and 9 times out of 10, you run the risk of me grabbing the handset and throwing it into the gutter. Tell me that you’re ‘happy with your N73’ but that you are ‘being careful with your data usage’ and there’s no going back: I’ll insist you take the handset back to the shop and swap it for a shit 6200 Nokia. I’ll wait while you do it to make sure it happens. That, or the phone deserves to be rammed where the sun doesn’t shine.

Promise me this: If we get to June next year and there’s no change, if you’re all still flouncing around worrying about your data bills, promise me you’ll swap your contract to T-Mobile.

Do you know, I am willing to bet that the vast majority of the people I met at Swedish Beers last month fall into the above ‘excellent phone, but I don’t use it properly ‘cos of the data cost’ category — and that is ridiculous.

Either swallow the £3/meg cost, stop worrying about your data usage and expense it, or get a T-Mobile 7.50/month plan.

It’s silly now. 6 months ago, with just a few handsets capable of high resolution imaging, 3g and video, fair enough. But now, with the next generation of 3.2 megapixel handsets out in the wild, all capable of delivering a huge array of data services, well, it’s just plain stupid.

When your phone can take a 400k 2 or 3 megapixel image, you should be able to painlessly send that to your favourite online service without having to resize it to 40k. You shouldn’t have to think that the image is gonna cost £1.50ish to upload. It shouldn’t be costing anywhere near that. Last month I did about 300 meg of data. Pictures, video, application usage, web browsing. At minimum you should be doing that too, if, in particular, you’re sitting there with a Nokia N73, N80, in fact any N series or camera-ready E series or Sony Ericsson K800.

You’re not worthy of your handset if it’s massively data capable and you’re sat there worrying about the data costs. Either swap to T-Mobile, put up with your existing operator data charges or go and buy yourself a £50 Sony CMD Z5 from ebay — you know, a phone that doesn’t do data.

To be clear, I’m no huge fan of T-Mobile per se. I think the £7.50 data deal is good. But I’m not necessarily suggesting everyone swap to them. I’m suggesting that waving your top of the line Nokia in my face whilst telling me that you only use it for calls and texts because of the ‘data costs’ is simply unacceptable.

4 COMMENTS

  1. I couldn’t agree more with you. I hate to see the mobile operators in India charge astronomical rates for data services like it’s gold they are selling.

    I use a unlimited data plan (the only operator to offer it in India is Airtel) and use about 425 MB per month on my non-multimedia BlackBerry 8700g. Since I am now getting the Pearl I’d be using it a lot more especially for mobile blogging.

    I’d love to see more operators come out with unlimited data plans. At least that way you don’t worry about your data bills.

  2. Ewan, one of your famous rants, but you have hit the nail on the head with this one. I can’t figure out why the operators can’t do the maths on this. Would they rather have 100 customers paying £10 a month for a meagre amount of data or 1000 customers paying £7.50 for all they can consume. Maybe their calculators are broken?

    I’ve just moved to T-Mobile based on the data deal (it’s actually 2GB), but I’ve not spoken to anyone yet who has been told to cease and desist for exceeding the allowance.

    Too early yet to say if I’m going to be a big user or not, but at least I can try without getting a nasty surprise at the end of the month.

    Usability, now that’s the next big challenge! So far the Opera browser is the best find – it’s really make a huge difference to the user experience. Well worth the £15 or so.

    Also, I’d like T-mobile to look at their pricing for wi-fi access. I think doing some limited minutes as a low cost add on to web’n’walk would be cool.

    Incidentally, I’m using the Vario 2 – it was a painful decision to move from my S60 Symbian. If I was rich like Ewan I’d buy a Nokia E61 (unless of course anyone from Nokia’s PR team is reading this and would like to send me a nice review one…..)

    So far I think the Symbian platform is superior to Microsoft, but this could just be until I get familair with the Vario.

    Jim

  3. Nice rant. The only problem is that T Mobile still haven’t released the N80, N73 or any other half decent devices. The only half decent official TM handset is the Vario2, and they have no stock of that.

    I upgraded to an N73 a month ago on Vodafone. I would have loved to move to TM, but they just didn’t have the handset (and I didn’t want to buy one for cash just to use on TM).

    I live in hope that Vodafone will bring out a sensible response to T Mobile’s web ‘n’ walk and 3’s 512Mb package.

    In terms of coverage, Voda is a good choice. Better to have expensive 3G data than free GPRS!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Recently Published

Is it time to subscribe to a printer service from HP?

Ever since my dad brought home an HP LaserJet printer (version 3, if memory serves), I have been printing with an HP. Over the...

What’s the best way of buying a phone today?

How did you buy your latest phone? I'm asking because I'm thinking about what I should be doing. When I was living in Oman, I...

MWC: What device highlights did you miss?

So, early last week I predicted that next to nothing from Mobile World Congress would break through into the mainstream media. I was right,...

How Wireless Will Pave the Path to Neobank Profitability

I'm delighted to bring you an opinion piece from Rafa Plantier at Gigs.com. I think it's particularly relevant given the recent eSIM news from...

An end of an era: Vodafone UK turns off 3G services

I thought it was worthwhile highlighting this one from the Vodafone UK team. For so long - for what feels like years, seeing the...

Mobile World Congress: Did the mainstream media notice?

I resolved this year to make sure I wrote something - anything - about Mobile World Congress, the huge mobile industry trade show taking...